The Oscars ended almost 48 hours ago and I haven’t blogged about them yet, so:
Crash over Brokeback Mountain: Eh. I found Crash contrived and manipulative, even if it did have interesting things to say about race, i.e. it’s better to acknowledge one’s latent racism than to deny it altogether. Brokeback was a just plain better film. It was beautifully made. I didn’t like it just because it was a “gay movie”; in fact, it didn’t move me like it did some other people. It was unfair for gay people to make the movie carry the weight of the gay rights movement on its back, just as it was unfair for homophobes to accuse the movie of furthering a gay agenda. But peel away all the cultural baggage that has glommed onto the film – take the film as a film – and it was better than Crash.
To be honest, though, I preferred Good Night, and Good Luck to them both. That was a terrific movie. Luscious black and white, beautiful jazz music sung by Dianne Reeves, an economical plot. Loved it.
I still haven’t seen Capote or Munich.
(Strangely, I haven’t yet read any comparisons to 1998/99, when Shakespeare in Love upset Saving Private Ryan for Best Picture. That outcome thrilled me – I thought Shakespeare in Love was brilliant and original and deserved to beat the dutiful, serious Saving Private Ryan. But I’ve come to see them both as terrific films.)
As for other Oscar stuff:
Best moment: Lily Tomlin and Meryl Streep introducing Robert Altman. Those two ladies have talent and class. I adore them.
The fake campaign ads were also great and the most Daily-Show-esque parts of the evening, aside from Jon Stewart himself.
Jon Stewart did not do as well as I’d hoped. Or maybe it’s just that the audience didn’t seem to get him. But he made a valiant effort. Later on in the show, he had some good moments, particularly after the Oscar for Best Song was announced. Much of Jon Stewart’s genius lies in his facial expressions. He can do so much without saying a word.
Speaking of best song: “It’s Hard Out Here for a Pimp”… Huh???
Toby Ziegler’s ex-wife singing in front of burning cars and interpretive dancers: Whaaah?
Aren’t there usually five nominees for best song?
Does Jack Nicholson have a lifetime guarantee of a front-row seat? And what’s with his glasses every year?
Poor Lauren Bacall. She needed glasses, I think.
Montages: oh my god. People do not watch the Oscars for the montages. I love me a good Chuck Workman montage, but four montages? One was enough.
March of the Penguins: I shouldn’t criticize a movie I haven’t seen. So I won’t.
Playing music underneath the acceptance speeches was distracting. We’ve been conditioned to hear the music as the signal to wrap things up, so that was confusing.
Boo on all the co-winners who hogged the microphone without letting their co-winners speak.
All in all, the Oscars came in at a smidge under three and a half hours. They could have been shorter, but at least they weren’t longer.
I thought Jon Stewart was great. I missed the first hour, and I heard he warmed up as he went along, but I thought his ad-libs were extremely good. I think the TV audience probably got him more than the Kodak Theater crowd. I loved the “If you’re ever in a burning car, I do not recommend fleeing in slow motion” line.
March of the Penguins. You really ought to see it. Beautiful, and beautifully narrated by Morgan Freeman, who apparently has some special exemption from the Academy allowing him to have an open collar on Oscar night.
And in terms of criticism, you left out them cutting off the Best Picture winners! What was up with THAT?
THAT’s who that was! I stopped watching “The West Wing” years ago, and couldn’t figure out why that woman looked so familiar. Thank you!
“Aren’t there usually five nominees for best song?”
Yup.
But there was a new process for choosing the Best Song nominees this year. The members of the music branch gathered to watch the movie scenes in which each of the nominees was heard, then each member rated each song from 6 to 10 (Why not 1 to 5? Who knows?). The five highest-rated songs would be the nominees, but a minimum average rating of 8.25 was also required, and these were the only three songs that scored high enough to be nominated.
Yes, do see March of the Penguins. I never thought a nature documentary could move me so, but by golly, it did. Agreed, re: the montages. My TiVo didn’t catch the end of the broadcast (I should’ve padded the recording); they should’ve nixed the montages!
You’re aboslutely right. Good Night and Good Luck WAS the best picutre. And years from now it’ll be the only one anyone will be looking at.
Remember when Ordinary People beat out Raging Bull?
I could not agree more with Jeff and David E. – ‘Good Night, and Good Luck’ really WAS the best picture and it would have been great to see George Clooney win an Oscar for ‘Best Director’. And I haven’t even mentioned David Straithairn’s performance yet ..