Following up on my post last week about transgendered people and ENDA: John Aravosis further explains his opposition in the lead article on Salon.com today.
Key paragraph, about the importance of political pragmatism:
Conservatives understand that cultural change is a long, gradual process of small but cumulatively deadly victories. Liberals want it all now. And that’s why, in the culture wars, conservatives often win and we often lose. While conservatives spend years, if not decades, trying to convince Americans that certain judges are “activists,” that gays “recruit” children, and that Democrats never saw an abortion they didn’t like, we often come up with last-minute ideas and expect everyone to vote for them simply because we’re right. Conservatives are happy with piecemeal victory, liberals with noble failure. We rarely make the necessary investment in convincing people that we’re right because we consider it offensive to have to explain an obvious truth. When it comes time to pass legislation, too many liberals just expect good and virtuous bills to become law by magic, without the years of legwork necessary to secure a majority of the votes in Congress and the majority support of the people. We expect our congressional allies to fall on their swords for us when we’ve failed to create a culture in which it’s safe for politicians to support our agenda and do the right thing. ENDA, introduced for the first time 30 years ago, is an exception to that rule. It took 30 years to get to the point where the Congress and the public are in favor of legislation banning job discrimination against gays. It’s only been five months since transgendered people were included in ENDA for the first time.
I think Aravosis protests too much about not “passing judgment” on transgendered people, but his point is still sound.
Isn’t this a huge generalization? Both parties always have to make a lot of compromises. My thinking is that if there was a bill about racial discrimination and some politicians were adamant about not including Hispanics, it would be really difficult to let that bill pass without a fight.
I don’t think conservatives are nearly as happy as you think with piecemeal victories, and I don’t think — with the exception of abortion — that conservatives feel that they’re winning the “culture wars”.